Dear Muir Glen, I Need More From This Relationship
May 2 
Dear Muir Glen,
If you want us to be together, I’m going to need more out of this relationship. Hear me out, would you?
We broke up because you and I had different needs. I needed to be able to make pot after pot of chili without feeling like I was serving up BPA stew all the time. You needed to keep your price point reasonable, given that there weren’t any obvious substitutions you felt you could make to your can liners.
We had, in short, irreconcilable differences.
Then, we had a post break-up chat. I sent you this little breezy message:
11/10/09: I love your products, but I have a question. I see on the label that the can has a "white enamel coating." Have you tested for BPA? Thank you, S.P.
You replied:
Dear Ms. Pinneo:
Thank you for contacting Muir Glen regarding bisphenol-A in food packaging. Bisphenol-A is a critical component of protective coatings used with metal food packaging and provides important quality and safety features to canned foods.
Scientific and government bodies worldwide have examined the scientific evidence and consistently have reached the conclusion that BPA is not a risk to human health. Recent examples include comprehensive risk assessments in Japan and Europe and a review by an independent panel of experts organized by the Harvard Center for Risk Analysis. The can coatings used in Muir Glen packaging comply with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration requirements for use in food contact applications. These coatings have long played an essential part in food preservation, helping to maintain wholesomeness, nutritional value, and product quality.
We work closely with our suppliers to ensure that all of the food ingredients and packaging materials we use are fully in compliance with U.S. Food and Drug Administration requirements and meet our high quality standards.
We will continue to monitor this situation. If you have any further questions, please feel free to contact us. Your questions and comments are always welcome. For more information on the safety of metal food containers, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration press office may be contacted at (301) 436-2335.
Sincerely,
Craig Grey
Consumer Services
To be honest, I didn’t like your reply very much. I felt the need to restate my objections. I wrote:
Dear Mr. Grey,
I have thus far enjoyed Muir Glen products, but I feel your approach is wrong-headed here. It is no coincidence that the email address from which your reply comes is "Corporate.Response@..." Your answer is very much a corporate response. I am quite sure that the Muir Glen line complies with FDA regulations. But the public tide against BPA is turning very much against this product. In fact, it is likely to be outlawed a ways down the road. Why not get ahead of the curve? You make an otherwise wholesome product. People are tired of learning that companies they've trusted use BPA in their packaging. Every mother at our school is horribly annoyed at SIGG for the water bottle revelation.
Get ahead of the game here. Get rid of the BPA.
S.
And you wrote… nothing. And so that was it between us. And even though many of my friends really love you, and it was awkward at parties, we’ve been apart for quite a while now.
And I’ve been coping on my own. There were a few lonely Friday nights, but I pulled through. I flirted with other tomato products, I batted my eyes at tetra-packs and glass bottles. If you must know, I have a big crush on glass bottles these days. In my darker moments I wonder why you can’t just put your tomatoes in glass bottles, so that we could be together again.
Even the FDA has recommended limiting BPA for children, even if they're too wimpy to outlaw it entirely. And then there was that bombshell study published in Pediatrics, which (although it was a small study with a couple of flaws) has implications even more dramatic than I ever would have imagined.
So you were the last one I expected to pop up on twitter a few months ago, with a note just for me:
To which I said:
And then you said… nothing. For months.
Listen, I’m flattered by this semi-recent gesture—really I am. And I do love progress. But I hope you know it’s going to take a little extra love to heal the rift between us. If the problem is on its way to being solved, I’m going to have more than a few questions about how. If your new cans are BPA free, great. But I’m going to need to know what else might be in there. Is it something more stable? Less chemically interesting? Would I be able to spell it on the first try?
Parents’ trust of corporations has changed in the last decade. Remember when fast food restaurants felt free to advertise their “secret sauce?” Those days are over. We can’t take any more secrets, please. We’re more alert now. More knowing. So if you have an improvement to make, let it be good and thorough.
I’ve had my heart broken once already. I’m not going to go through that again.
Tentatively yours,
S.P.
;){kind=link}
Reader Comments (6)
I had no idea. Gutted. Sigh. Thank you, I guess. Guess I'll go plant more tomatoes and store my own for the winter months...I swear the corporate inability to do the right thing before legal action is waged against them is pushing me ever closer to commune living.
Amanda--you are right. I held my breath last month when the FDA almost decided to ban BPA. Instead we are left with a substance which is legal... yet our own government says to avoid it when pregnant or for small children.
When I write about this topic, I try so hard not to sound yappy and hysterical. But my trust is constantly eroded by failure to act. Thank you for reading!
Last year, I called Muir Glen to learn how to know if my cans were made from a allegedly BPA-free liner. They told me if it was white, it was the old BPA can but if it had an orange color, it did not contain BPA. I did fail to ask them what it was made of, but it appeared to be orange from the tomatoes in the can. I would love to hear what you find out.
It's so incredibly frustrating. The FDA's findings was so disappointing. A big thank you for your efforts. If we all continue to question and demand safer foods perhaps some day soon corporations will listen.
What?
Oh, dear. I need to pay attention to this stuff a whole lot more!
Sarah
I think we are on the same page with our focus! Thanks so much for the visit after theFrom Left To Write book club. I really enjoyed Julia's Child and will make sure to visit your blog often. Glad to have stirred up that entrepreneurial spirit in you, I could spot it a mile away!
Alison